What Is Gestalt Coaching? A Critical Review of The Fertile Void by John Leary-Joyce

The Fertile Void: Gestalt Coaching at Work was written by John Leary-Joyce, founder of the Academy of Executive Coaching, and published by AoEC Press in 2014. It grew from his experience in Gestalt psychotherapy, coaching and coach development, and helps explain the Gestalt influence within the AoEC coaching tradition.

This is not a conventional management book offering a sequence of steps to follow. It presents a way of paying attention to what is happening in a coaching conversation and using that awareness to support change. That difference is both its main strength and the reason it needs to be used with care.

What Gestalt coaching means

Gestalt coaching looks at the person as a whole rather than treating a leadership problem as an isolated behaviour. Thoughts, emotions, physical responses, relationships and the surrounding environment may all contain useful information. The coach pays attention not only to the story being told, but to how the individual is telling it and what appears to be happening in the present moment.

A leader may say they are comfortable with a decision while speaking hesitantly, changing the subject or becoming visibly tense. A Gestalt approach does not assume that the coach knows what this means. It notices the discrepancy and invites the individual to become curious about it.

Awareness before action

Many coaching models move quickly towards a goal and action plan. Gestalt coaching gives greater importance to awareness. The argument is that people often repeat a pattern because they do not fully recognise what they are doing, what they are avoiding or how they affect others.

When awareness becomes clearer, a different choice becomes possible. For a senior leader, this might mean noticing the urge to take control whenever a colleague disagrees, the tendency to fill every silence, or the physical tension that appears before a difficult conversation.

This does not mean action is unimportant. It means action follows a more complete understanding of the present situation.

The idea of the fertile void

The title describes the uncomfortable space between letting go of an established pattern and knowing what will replace it. Leaders are often expected to move quickly, appear certain and provide answers. The idea of a fertile void suggests that not knowing can sometimes be productive.

If the coach or client rushes to fill that space with advice, an action list or a familiar solution, something important may be missed. Staying with uncertainty for longer can allow a different insight to emerge. This is particularly relevant when the obvious solution has already been tried or the issue involves identity, relationships or competing needs.

The risk is that uncertainty becomes an end in itself. A business leader still has decisions to make. The value lies in using reflection to improve action, not in avoiding action indefinitely.

Experiment rather than merely discuss

The book is practical in the Gestalt sense. It describes active experimentation, bodywork and applications to team coaching. An experiment is a safe way of making a pattern more visible or trying something different during the session.

A leader might repeat a statement with clearer authority, change position to consider another stakeholder’s perspective, remain silent instead of immediately explaining, or notice what happens physically while describing a conflict. The purpose is not performance or theatre. It is to create fresh information that ordinary discussion may not produce.

Used skilfully, experiments make coaching immediate and memorable. Used badly, they can feel artificial, intrusive or disconnected from the client’s purpose. Consent and judgement matter.

The relationship is part of the work

Gestalt coaching treats the interaction between coach and client as useful information. If the coach feels confused, pushed away or drawn into solving the problem, that reaction may reflect something the leader also creates in other relationships.

The coach can offer this observation carefully and as a possibility, not a verdict. This requires a strong level of self-awareness. The coach must distinguish between a response that may be useful to the client and something arising from their own history, preference or mood.

Where the approach is strong

The strongest aspect of The Fertile Void is its attention to what conventional problem solving can overlook. Senior leaders are often intellectually capable and able to produce a convincing explanation for almost any decision. A purely rational conversation may leave the underlying pattern untouched.

Gestalt coaching can expose the gap between intention and impact. It is useful when a leader understands what they should do but continues to behave differently under pressure. It also respects complexity. Rather than reducing somebody to a personality type, it examines how behaviour changes across situations and relationships.

The approach can be particularly valuable for presence, confidence, conflict, transitions and team dynamics, where the quality of contact between people matters as much as the content of a plan.

Where the approach has limitations

Gestalt language can feel abstract to a commercially focused client. Concepts such as awareness, contact and the fertile void need to be translated into the decisions and results that matter in the role. Without that connection, the coaching may be interesting but difficult to evaluate.

The quality of the work also depends heavily on the coach. Noticing body language or emotional shifts does not give somebody the right to interpret them as fact. An overconfident coach can impose meaning, take an experiment too far or move into therapeutic territory without an appropriate contract or competence.

Gestalt coaching is not the answer to every leadership problem. If responsibilities are unclear, resources are missing or performance expectations have not been stated, greater awareness alone will not repair the system. Some clients also need direct advice, technical learning or a simple action framework alongside deeper exploration.

Who will find the book useful

The book is most useful to coaches and experienced leaders who want to understand what happens beneath the words in a development conversation. Its practical examples and exercises make the approach more accessible, but readers expecting a short checklist may find it less immediate than GROW or other structured models.

It should be read as an invitation to develop observation and presence, not as permission to analyse people. The more experiential the method becomes, the more important supervision, ethical boundaries and appropriate training are.

A balanced conclusion

The Fertile Void offers a valuable correction to coaching that moves too quickly from problem to action. It reminds us that leaders are not machines to be adjusted and that meaningful change often begins with noticing what is already happening.

Its limitation is the reverse of its strength. An open, emergent approach can lack focus if it is not connected to a clear coaching purpose and real organisational outcomes. In experienced hands, Gestalt can deepen executive coaching considerably. Used as a collection of techniques or interpretations, it can become vague or intrusive.

The most sensible conclusion is not that Gestalt should replace structured coaching models. It is that awareness, relationship and experimentation can help a coach understand when a neat model is missing the real issue.

ACS Executive Performance uses coaching approaches flexibly rather than forcing every client through one system. The method should serve the individual, the situation and the improvement the organisation needs to see.

Next
Next

Cognitive Behavioural Coaching: Can Changing Thought Patterns Improve Leadership Performance?